Book Review: The Disenchantments

The Disenchantments
By Nina LaCour
Dutton Children’s Books
Ages 14 and up
Author’s Website
Hardcover | Kindle

Colby and Bev have a long-standing pact: graduate, hit the road with Bev’s band, and then spend the year wandering around Europe. But moments after the tour kicks off, Bev makes a shocking announcement: she’s abandoning their plans – and Colby – to start college in the fall.

But the show must go on and The Disenchantments weave through the Pacific Northwest, playing in small towns and dingy venues, while roadie- Colby struggles to deal with Bev’s already-growing distance and the most important question of all: what’s next?


THE DISENCHANTMENTS is nearly everything I hope for when it comes to good contemporary reading. It’s gritty, it’s fun and at its core it’s an emotional piece about being at the cusp of the rest of your life. It portrays a week in the lives of four friends who are on the edge of either glory or failure. Recently graduated from high school, Colby, Bev, Meg and (soon to be free, after just one more year of high school) Alexa set out on the road trip of a lifetime, touring the northwest coast in their (not so good) grrl rock band (Colby is the “roadie”). It’s so much more than the cover makes it out to be.

Plot: 8

Upon reading the blurb above, the story sounds fairly straight forward: boy joins band on tour, boy secretly loves girl, girl lays major bombshell on boy. But really, this books shows us so much more than that. It was refreshing to read a story from a male perspective. A male with strong emotions and opinions. A male with a very miniscule sense of “self”. This is his story, as well as the story of the rest of the band, their families and the people they meet along the way. In a way, it is a story fairly similar to that told in the feel-good book, Where the Heart Is. (Ever hear of that one? I honestly couldn’t help but make comparisons while reading. Good comparisons.) The bombshell given to Colby in the beginning is a Big One, and I’m fairly certain he felt much like Novalee did when she was abandoned at a Walmart in the middle of nowhere. He then encounters numerous people on his continued journey, encounters that lead him to his ultimate destiny (more or less).

My only gripe is that I really, REALLY hope there will be a sequel… I grew to love these guys so much that I really want to know what happens to them next. Also, there were more than a few loose threads left in the end; a couple giant question marks that I’m dying to have answered.

Characters: 8

There’s a girl on the cover, but the story is told by a boy. Got that? Good. I fell in love with Colby for all his insight-fulness, his artistic talent similar to my own, his connection to the world and all the things in it. He really is my kind of guy. I love him for his innocence and for his innocence lost. I love him because his voice is what drives the story along. He may be a slightly emotional boy, but I am very grateful that throughout the book I never forget that he was, indeed, a boy. Some authors fall into a gutter when trying to depict the point of view of a male protagonist. Nina LaCour pulls it off with artistic precision.

I also loved the characters, Meg and Alexa. They are polar opposites, and the adopted daughters of two gay male partners. One (Alexa) is stuck in the hippie karma-loving 70’s and the other (Meg) is the poster child of the 80’s. Their stories and the secrets they have to share really made me feel connected to them in a way I didn’t think I would going into the book. The same can be said about the plethora of other characters introduced along their road trip.

The only character I had some issues with is Bev. She was a real mystery for most of the book, and because of this I had a very hard time sympathizing with her, even up to the very last page. I can see why Colby loves her, but man! – she didn’t quite win me over… She is one of the major reasons I desperately want a sequel. I really do WANT to like her!

Setting: 10

Road trip! Who here doesn’t like road trip novels? Raise your hand. If your hand is raised, then perhaps this book isn’t for you. We spend most of the book either in a VW bus, a hotel room or in some stranger’s house. Each location has a personality all its own and Nina has an artistic (there’s that darn “artsy” word again!) way of making it flow with the story in both mood and tone. She also uses the setting to flesh out her characters, which is a must for any road trip novel. Nina LaCour excels in this area. So if (like me) you love road trip stories and meeting plenty of new faces along the way, this book will be right up your alley.

Pacing: 10

The story is told in only the matter of a handful of days. Each day receives its own chapter. Plenty of detail is given in every chapter. Each location has some impact on the overall story. Few words are wasted, and few characters met along the way can be considered insignificant. Whether or not you like every stop is up to you, but I loved meeting both those who do little more than discuss something as simple as having a “type” of beer as well as those who contribute in greater ways, like making us contemplate the different aspects of “love”. It’s the diversity of the situations involved that make every piece of the story that much more engrossing. The pacing is spot on because of this, even if you do wish that you knew exactly what the heck is up with some of these characters as you’re reading.

Style: 9

This book just lets you be one of the band. By writing the story in the point of view of a male roadie, Nina has thrown a wrench into her story that differentiates it from other contemporary YA. Her writing style is smart and cool all at the same time. No excuses, it’s all laid out there to the reader. She knows how to keep the dialogue real and far away from “wooden” territory. But one thing that also comes with realistic language in the “rock and roll” world of our youth is some fairly strong language. This prudish mommy will accept that, but 1 Style point is also taken away because of it. (Booo, Hiss! Prudish mommy!!!) Also included within these pages is talk of drug use, underage drinking, sex and sexuality.

Will this book provide you with the answers to the meaning of life? No. But it will provide you with plenty of hours of escapism, where you can once again (or for the first time ever) stand on the precipice between being a child and growing up. And THAT my friends makes for a mighty fine book indeed.

Grade: 95


About Jenna (Does Books)

Working momma of a little pink princess and reader of all things YA. I'm an artist, writer and avid reader who swears that she's having a hard time letting go of the childish things... Let me read your latest YA book and let's see if it makes the grade!

Posted on March 2, 2012, in Book Review, Four & 1/2 Star and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 1 Comment.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: